Search
  • yiphoifung

Book review: Where the Crawdads Sing by Delia Owens

Updated: Jun 25, 2020

Where the Crawdads Sing, the debut novel by natural scientist Delia Owens, has achieved phenomenal success since its publication last year.


The novel is set in a marshland in North Carolina in the 1950s and 1960s. Hidden in the maze of waterways is the shack of Kya, the protagonist, disparagingly called the "marsh girl" by those in town. Kya is the youngest of five children. After her beloved mother and siblings flee their abusive father one after another, Kya is left fending for herself, deprived of familial love and education. Her only source of sustenance, as well as consolation for loneliness, is the rich wildlife of the marsh.


Thanks to help from Tate, a young boy who shares Kya's love of the otherworldly beauty of the marsh, Kya learns to read and write. Passion grows between the two, but when Tate gets an offer from university and, much to his regret, leaves Kya without saying goodbye, Kya's only connection with the human world ends abruptly. Abandoned yet again, Kya comes to realise that all she needs is being left alone, but then the courtship of Chase, handsome and carefree, disrupts her solitude. Already disillusioned by the way of the world, will she give it one more chance?


The depiction of Kya's longings and disillusionment intertwines with the investigation of a murder — the murder of Chase. The two alternating timelines converge and culminate in the trial of Kya and an ending that is both surprising and fitting.


To me, Where the Crawdads Sing is as much a novel as an encyclopedia of wildlife of North Carolina marshlands. The dazzling array of flora and fauna attests to the author's knowledge and love of the natural world. When Tate seeks to approach Kya, he leaves behind feathers on a stump — first a feather of a great blue heron ("A great blue heron is the color of gray mist reflecting in blue water"), followed by "a magnificent tail feather of a tropicbird" and ultimately a "silver and soft" feather from the crest of a night heron, "one of the most beautiful of the marsh".


But it is the interweaving of the author's observation — through Kya's eyes — of animal behaviour and Kya's interpretation of the dynamics of the outside world that marks the book's literary distinctiveness. One example is how she makes sense of her mum's falling for her dad. To Kya, her dad was like a pint-sized male bullfrog that is "not strong, adorned, or smart enough to hold good territories", but "struts about" pretentiously to attract a mate. The study of animal behaviour, academically referred to as ethology, also holds the key to solving the murder case, the details of which I am not disclosing here.


Another distinctive, recurring motif is loneliness — first foisted upon Kya who then seems to embrace it willingly. "She knew the years of isolation had altered her behavior until she was different from others, but it wasn't her fault she'd been alone. Most of what she knew, she'd learned from the wild. Nature had nurtured, tutored, and protected her when no one else would," writes the author. In fact, Delia Owens has said that Where the Crawdads Sing is indeed "about loneliness", adding that "I have lived an isolated and lonely life."


That being its pervading mood, Where the Crawdads Sing is more than a celebration of nature — it is also one of solitude and remoteness. "Far from the madding crowd", to borrow the title of Thomas Hardy's classic.


◆About the author

Delia Owens published this novel, her first and a New York Times bestseller, last year at the age of 69, though she had written three scientific books with her then husband previously.


◆What does the title mean?

The crawdad is the North America term for a freshwater crayfish. As the author said in an interview, as a young girl she was encouraged by her mother to go as far as "where the crawdads sing", i.e. to explore nature as deeply as possible.


◆What to expect?

Depictions of nature in poetic language with profuse use of tropes. A murder mystery and a coming-of-age story.


◆A difficult read?

The opening chapters can be hard as they overflow with animal and plant names, but midway into the novel you should turn the pages much more swiftly having got quite familiar with those names.


Originally published in Ming Pao, a Hong Kong newspaper, on 22 October 2019.

2 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

英語深度遊:從「歐超聯」談英語單眾數(下)

上期談到集合名詞(collective nouns)的英美之別,以及英國球會在什麼時候配搭單數或眾數動詞。那麼美國體壇,如港人熟悉的國家籃球協會(NBA)和美國職業棒球聯賽(MLB),情况又怎樣呢? 如果讀者有留意相關新聞,便會知道這些賽事的球隊名字也會配搭眾數動詞。以下是 MLB 的例子: ‧The Red Sox Confront a New Curse(《紐約時報》) 上期提到英超球隊之所以

從「歐超聯」談英語單眾數(上)

若讀者是球迷,應知道最近的球壇大事,莫過於歐洲超級聯賽(European Super League)的鬧劇。12支歐洲豪門球會擬另起爐灶,建立不設升降班制度的聯賽,詎料引發風暴,群情洶湧之下,列強相繼退出,計劃遂告胎死腹中。英國體育專欄作家 Jonathan Liew 更痛批這12支球會為「the dirty dozen」,他解釋了這些富豪球會另起爐灶的財政原因: ‧Barcelona are

新聞報道,運用什麼時態?

英語有一個說法,說重要的新聞是history in the making,指的是某些事件舉足輕重,正在締造歷史。其實不論大至緬甸政變、小至某地某人中巨獎,新聞都必定是過去發生的。即使事態仍在發展,記者能夠用文字捕捉的都必然過去。那麼用過去式(Past tense)報道新聞,似是理所當然。 但不論瀏覽 BBC 還是 The New York Times(《紐約時報》),總會看到以現在式(Presen